• Analysis
Norm Coleman conflict of interest questions shadow his Pentagon Defense Policy Board role
Norm Coleman, an informal adviser to Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth and vice chairman of the Defense Policy Board since June, is a registered lobbyist for Saudi Arabia and a senior adviser to Israeli weapons company Kinetica. Ethics watchdogs call the combination a conflict of interest, though it is not illegal.

Norm Coleman holds a formal seat advising the Pentagon while simultaneously working as a lobbyist for Saudi Arabia and a senior adviser to an Israeli weapons company. Ethics watchdogs say the norm Coleman conflict of interest arrangement is legal but self-serving, and none of the parties involved responded to requests for comment.
From Hegseth's nomination to the Defense Policy Board
Coleman, a former Republican senator from Minnesota, became an informal guide to Pete Hegseth starting in December 2024, during Hegseth's nomination as defense secretary. At Hegseth's Senate armed services committee hearing - a session lasting 4 hours and 24 minutes that covered allegations of sexual misconduct, workplace drinking and marital infidelity - Hegseth thanked Coleman for his mentorship and friendship during the process.
- •In June, Hegseth appointed Coleman to the Defense Policy Board as vice chairman.
- •The board advises on strategic planning, the policy implications of US force structure and modernization, regional defense policies and other national security matters.
Lobbying for Saudi Arabia and advising Kinetica
Outside the Pentagon, Coleman chairs the Republican Jewish Coalition and the Congressional Leadership Fund, and works as a registered lobbyist for Saudi Arabia. He is also senior adviser to Kinetica, an Israeli weapons company.
His lobbying practice extends further. As senior counsel at Hogan Lovells Cadwalader, Coleman lobbied for Hidden Level Inc, a drone detection company, contacting the defense and homeland security departments and the White House. He helped raise the profile of SkyWater Technology as a trusted domestic semiconductor manufacturer on behalf of client Coretsu, and after his Defense Policy Board appointment he remained a lobbyist on the Bear SVTP Development LLC account, concerning land development for AI data centers and federal regulation.
Kinetica has publicized the appointment. The company reported that Coleman, speaking at a Tel Aviv conference, shared his perspective drawn from his deep proximity to the US defense establishment. Kinetica also wrote that the Pentagon is increasingly open to emerging innovation, representing a significant opportunity to scale into the American defense ecosystem. Its LinkedIn post said Coleman's appointment reflects the firm's thesis that defense policy, technological superiority and allied innovation are one national security mission.
Watchdogs: legal but self-serving
Craig Holman of Public Citizen said: "Norm Coleman is a walking conflict of interest on the Pentagon Defense Policy Board". Holman noted that most other advisory boards will not allow the appointment of registered lobbyists, and that the Federal Advisory Committee Act bans individual lobbyists - but not those who serve as lobbyists for another firm like Hogan Lovells. Working simultaneously as a lobbyist and advising the Pentagon is not illegal, and Holman said Coleman's situation does not seem to be illegal, just self-serving and unethical.
"But it doesn't seem to be illegal, just self-serving and unethical."
Jeff Hauser of the Revolving Door Project said it is impossible for one's work for the United States to fail to influence one's work for Saudi Arabia or defense companies. Hauser added that serving successfully as a sherpa to a controversial nominee tends to breed enormous goodwill - as Coleman did for Hegseth.
A board with a precedent, and a wider Israel debate
The Defense Policy Board has faced similar scrutiny before. A 2003 Center for Public Integrity investigation found nine of thirty board members had ties to contractors holding more than $76bn in Pentagon contracts, and four were registered lobbyists. Then-chairman Richard Perle resigned over business ties to Global Crossing and Loral Space & Communications, though a Pentagon inspector general report concluded he did not violate any ethics laws.
The Coleman questions land amid a broader push for deeper US-Israel defense integration:
- •Section 219 of the House National Defense Authorization Act would commit the US to bilateral research and development and co-production of weapons with Israel.
- •Mark Dubowitz, CEO of the Foundation for Defense of Democracies, wrote in Israel Hayom that Israel and the United States should deepen their military, technological, intelligence and economic integration, arguing that declining US public support for Israel should concern the country because public opinion shapes policy.
- •FDD board member Isaac Applbaum is chairman of Kinetica; his son, Kinetica founding partner Aaron Applbaum, told Defense Brief in June: "It's a generational opportunity to start a new platform".
Stephen Miller, now White House chief of staff, has issued a memo ordering White House staffers to get approval before meeting lobbyists. Coleman, Hogan Lovells Cadwalader and Kinetica did not respond to requests for comment, and Coleman's Pentagon role continues alongside his lobbying accounts.



