• Analysis
Killer Robots Regulation Stalls as 128 Nations Meet in Geneva
Envoys from 128 nations met in Geneva on Monday to decide whether to open negotiations on legally binding rules for autonomous weapon systems that can kill without human input, at the UN Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons Review Conference.

A consensus rule meets a divided room
Government envoys from 128 nations gathered in Geneva on Monday to decide whether talks should begin on writing legally binding rules for autonomous weapon systems. The meeting is the Review Conference for the UN's Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons, and under the convention all decisions must be reached by consensus.
That rule matters, because the room is split. A majority of member states support binding regulation of autonomous weapons in principle, yet major arms-producing countries including the US and Russia have consistently opposed such a pact. A single holdout can therefore block the killer robots regulation a majority says it wants.
Ukraine brings the debate to the battlefield
The war in Ukraine has turned the question from hypothetical to operational. Moscow and Kyiv have both used lethal drones fitted with AI-powered guidance that can identify and strike pre-programmed targets even after losing contact with their human operator. Both countries are believed to be testing attack drones that go further still, choosing their own targets rather than only locking onto ones selected by humans.
Vincent Boulanin, a senior researcher and director of the Governance and Artificial Intelligence Programme at the Swedish International Peace Research Institute, said drones on both sides are still to a large extent remotely piloted, but increasingly depend on automated targeting to finish missions when communications are denied. What is new, he said, is offensive 'last-mile' targeting, with autonomy used to complete attacks where remote control is not technically feasible, including reported use against human targets.
Ukrainian forensic investigators believe six Russian drones that hit a petrol station in Zaporizhzhia in September, killing three people, were guided entirely by AI. New York Times reporting on the strike suggests the first fully autonomous killing by drone may already have occurred.
Boulanin said the change is that a discussion once confined to the future has arrived in the present, with weapons completing attacks on their own. As he put it, "What has changed is that what used to be considered a futuristic debate is now something that is very tangible and real".
Ten years of talk, no treaty
Autonomous weapons have been discussed at the Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons for more than 10 years, Boulanin said, with the core concern being who decides on the use of force when an algorithm identifies, prioritises and attacks targets. States agree that, ultimately, humans or commanders are the ones responsible for decisions under international law, and the debate is how autonomy affects their ability to ensure lawful use.
There is also a long-standing acceptance to explain. States have developed autonomous weapon systems for defensive purposes for decades, such as against incoming missiles, and Boulanin said these uses were broadly seen as constrained to specific cases and predictable.
Reformers had a model: the 1995 Protocol on Blinding Laser Weapons, which Boulanin noted was one of the first times states agreed to ban a technology that had not yet been properly deployed, and which NGOs hoped to replicate for autonomous weapons. The effort failed, he said, partly because autonomous weapons can take so many shapes and forms and be used across conflict scenarios from asymmetric warfare to high-intensity US-China conflict at sea - unlike anti-personnel landmines.
Why the opponents hold out
Russia, the US and to some extent Israel have opposed a legally binding treaty since the convention's very beginning, according to Boulanin, who added that the US under the Trump administration has taken a much harder line. He attributed US resistance in part to its high-stakes competition with China and the need to plan for a possible major conflict, and said Israel wants to keep using the technology in its war against Hamas.
In his view, historical progress on weapon bans has depended on documented humanitarian harm and political appetite for consensus, and today's political conditions make binding regulation very difficult - at least the legally binding kind.
The Geneva conference must now decide by consensus whether negotiations begin at all, and with the US and Russia among the opposed, the outcome remains blocked by the same division that has stalled the file for a decade.



