• Analysis
France protests enter fifth round as demonstrators focus anger on police self-defence bill
Between 106,000 and 200,000 people joined the fifth Saturday of France protests, with the day's focus at the Paris rally on a parliamentary bill that would give police who use their weapons more protection.

For the fifth Saturday in a row, protesters marched through French cities, and in Paris the day belonged less to cost-of-living grievances than to one piece of legislation: a bill now before parliament that would change how police who use their weapons are treated by the law.
The bill dividing the streets
Adrien, a 20-year-old cello player in a volunteer orchestra at the Paris rally, said the focus of the day was the new bill. His worry was personal as well as political: tear gas fell on protesting musicians at a rally last month.
"We're scared when we come to a protest, and this will only make us even more afraid if their impunity is strengthened."
Backers of the bill, including Marine Le Pen's far-right party, argue that a law presuming police acted in self-defence is needed so officers are not automatically suspected of using disproportionate force. Activists counter that it would amount to a "licence to kill", hampering the opening of investigations and making police accountability harder in a country where alleged brutality cases rarely reach a criminal court.
How many marched
The competing counts for the day, reported as context by the interior ministry and student unions:
- •The interior ministry counted around 106,000 demonstrators nationwide, including 24,000 in Paris - the lowest turnout in recent weeks.
- •Student unions put the figure at 200,000, including almost 100,000 in the capital.
- •The ministry said 219 people were detained across the nation; Paris prosecutors said 45 were arrested in the capital, fewer than at previous mass protests.
For scale, the largest recent demonstrations came during a union-led strike on Thursday last week, when official figures counted more than half a million people nationwide.
Who is protesting and why
On the Paris march, a protester shouting into a megaphone declared "No justice, no peace". Some in the crowd called for the president to resign and chanted "Everybody hates the police", while one group carried a giant puppet whose hat read "Lord Macron".
In Bordeaux, Josette, a 72-year-old demonstrator, sang the protest song "I have two passions: brass bands and revolution". She said her children did not want her to come, but that she was grateful to the young for starting the movement.
"They're giving us hope at a time when it feels like we're heading straight for disaster"
In Toulouse, Kenza, a 28-year-old asylum law specialist, condemned the treatment of young demonstrators: "The repression of protesters is unacceptable – even more so when they are children."
Background to the movement
The movement has gripped France for more than a month, mixing high-school blockades with mass demonstrations. Several pressures surround the fifth Saturday:
- •Lawyers said last week that police violence at recent protests had caused "mutilations", including hand, foot and eye injuries.
- •In Lyon, police had to intervene to protect a team of television reporters after protesters attacked them, local authorities said.
- •Recent polls put Emmanuel Macron's popularity at its lowest since he first became president in 2017, and the government has little leeway to meet protester demands as it struggles to reduce debt.
- •Polls project hard-left candidate Jean-Luc Mélenchon as runner-up in next year's elections, with the centre-right struggling to present a single strong contender.
The next step is already set: unions have called a new day of strikes on Tuesday, after rejecting a government promise to raise the minimum wage by 0.6 percent as "crumbs".



