• Analysis
Milburn youth unemployment review urges tax cuts for hiring young people
Former health secretary Alan Milburn on Wednesday published his year-long review into youth unemployment, calling on ministers to cut national insurance for companies that hire young workers and ease regulations. The proposals, pitched to help almost 1 million young people not in education or work, drew union warnings despite a warm welcome from business.

A new bargain with employers
At the centre of the 278-page report is a call for the government to make hiring young people easier and less risky. Milburn asked ministers to cut national insurance for companies that take on young workers, and proposed applying a "cautionary principle" when abolishing exploitative zero-hours contracts and slowing the rise in youth rates of the minimum wage.
"A new bargain needs to be struck between employers and government."
Writing in the report, Milburn set out the two sides of that bargain: employers creating more first chances, and government shouldering the risk of hiring. "That is the give and the get," he said.
On pay floors, Milburn urged ministers to keep applying "caution" on youth rate increases, even though Labour promised in 2024 to raise the youth rate to the same level as the adult rate. He also warned against a full ban on zero-hours contracts: "There is a risk that in trying to address a legitimate challenge, the solution has unintended consequences. I believe this is likely to be the case".
What the review proposes and how it is paid for
The plan sets out where the money would go and how it would be raised:
- •Nearly £2bn a year on a youth opportunity service, offering every young person a guaranteed route into education, training or work
- •Just over £2bn for more vocational training courses and apprenticeships
- •A further £1bn in direct payments and tax breaks for companies hiring young people
- •Funding largely from replacing young people's disability and sickness benefits with a single youth allowance, set considerably below what some currently claim
Under the proposals, people aged 18-24 would no longer claim personal independence payments, with the new allowance available only to those whose conditions are "well established, significant and ongoing". Milburn calculated that the benefit cuts would save £3.6bn by 2036-37, with a further £2.4bn in higher tax receipts - sums that would be almost entirely swallowed by the £5.8bn cost of the new system. Ministers embraced the central recommendation of cutting benefit and sickness payments to fund more employment support.
Government and union reaction
The prime minister, Andy Burnham, called the publication a "watershed moment" for young people. Welcoming the report on Tuesday, he told cabinet colleagues it represented a "comprehensive vision" for changing the welfare, health and education systems to help young people into work. Work and pensions secretary Pat McFadden told MPs in the Commons that the government would deliver "a new settlement for young people".
Neither Burnham nor McFadden, however, explicitly backed Milburn's recommendations on national insurance contributions or zero-hours contracts. McFadden told the Commons on Tuesday: "We know that employment costs matter and we will consider all these things as we move forward".
Unions broadly welcomed the push to expand state support but cautioned against parts of the package. TUC general secretary Paul Nowak urged the government to "crack on and deliver its guaranteed hours rights in full", and argued that the past decade and a half had tested to destruction the idea that low-paid insecure work benefits the economy, calling that notion "for the birds". Usdaw general secretary Joanne Thomas said "crucial policies" on workers' rights must be retained and that employment must be fairly paid and secure.
Business pressure and the employment rights fight
Business leaders welcomed the recommendations, especially the tax cut for under-25s offsetting Labour's employer national insurance increase, starting in retail and hospitality. Recruitment and Employment Confederation interim chief executive Maxine Bligh said tackling the Neet crisis gives ministers the opportunity to reconsider a "guaranteed hours gamble that risks costing jobs".
Industry chiefs have intensified lobbying against the Employment Rights Act, finding a warm reception from Kemi Badenoch's Conservatives. Shadow chancellor Andrew Griffith accused Labour of pressing ahead with an "unemployment act" that would hit youth jobs, adding: "You cannot solve a youth jobs emergency without jobs, and this government has spent two years destroying them". Government analysis published this year estimated the employer costs of the reforms could range from £350m to £2.9bn a year, with a central estimate of £1.1bn.
Some in the sector pushed back on Milburn's approach. Timewise chief executive Clare McNeil said the charity disagrees with "any suggestion that the new responsibilities in the Employment Rights Bill will stop employers hiring". Unions and charities urged Burnham not to water down the plans, arguing that low-paid and insecure work had contributed significantly to Britain's youth jobs crisis.
Banning zero-hours contracts was a promise at the heart of Labour's election manifesto, and elements of the "make work pay" plan were watered down under Sir Keir Starmer amid business opposition. Allies of housing secretary Angela Rayner, who championed the zero-hours plan as Starmer's deputy, insisted her proposals would not discourage hiring; implementing the ban now falls to business secretary Jonathan Reynolds.



