• Analysis
Milburn says UK benefits bill will take a decade to come down: 'No such thing as a free lunch'
Former health secretary Alan Milburn said on Sunday that cutting the UK benefits bill for young people will take about 10 years, rejecting calls for rapid cuts ahead of his review's publication on Tuesday.

Alan Milburn has dismissed demands for swift reductions in out-of-work benefits for young people, saying it will take roughly a decade for the UK benefits bill to fall, as he prepares to publish his review into youth unemployment on Tuesday.
'Candid with people' on costs
Milburn, the former health secretary, told BBC's Sunday With Laura Kuenssberg that ministers would have to be "candid with people": he said the benefits bill would take 10 years to come down and to reach a "reasonable level" of youth unemployment. Additional investment in young people, he warned, would cost billions of pounds over that 10-year period.
Cutting the crisis faster was impossible without crude cuts, he said, and those would only make young people "show up somewhere else on the government ledger" - shifting costs elsewhere in public spending rather than removing them. Pressed on critics, including opposition leader Kemi Badenoch, who has repeatedly called for benefits to be slashed over a short period, he answered:
There's no such thing as a free lunch. If you are going to will the ends, you've got to will the means.
Milburn also said he did not believe anyone in the country considers it tolerable that 1 million people aged 16 to 24 are outside education, employment or training. Labour MPs, he argued, know their own constituencies contain hundreds, sometimes thousands, of young people "being doomed to a life on benefits".
About a million young people out of work and education
The review addresses a Neet population that has risen to about a million young people.
- •Around 1 million 16- to 24-year-olds are not in employment, education or training.
- •The Neet figure has risen to that level, the review notes.
- •Milburn says the scale of the crisis is something no one believes tolerable.
What the review will recommend
The report, which Milburn will publish on Tuesday, urges radical reforms in response to the youth unemployment crisis. It promises almost half a million job and education opportunities within a decade, alongside sweeping changes to benefits for under-25s.
On disability support, the recommendations include:
- •Some young people with disabilities would lose their ongoing personal independence payment (Pip) and instead apply to local funds for short-term expenses and equipment.
- •Entitlement would be protected for those with the most severe needs.
- •Most under-25s would no longer qualify for Pip or the health element of universal credit, receiving instead a new youth allowance paid at the standard universal credit rate.
Government signals compulsion and acknowledges losers
Work and pensions secretary Pat McFadden told Sky News the overhaul would carry an "element of compulsion" for Neets, with strengthened intervention to push young people into work or training. He pointed to countries that have succeeded on youth unemployment, such as the Netherlands, where teams "literally knock on your door" to offer training or work options.
McFadden, on the same BBC programme, acknowledged that some people would receive fewer benefits under the proposals. He justified the reductions by pointing to caseload growth: the number of young people claiming Pip has doubled since the start of the decade, and those on the health element of universal credit have risen by 80%.
Under-25s with long-term disabilities meaning they can never work, he said, "will actually get more than you will now". He also argued that someone who signs on to long-term sickness benefits at 20 has more chance of still being on them at 30 than of having a steady job in between.
The review publishes on Tuesday. The government expects opposition from Labour's left-wing MPs, who rebelled against Keir Starmer's plans to reform welfare last summer.



