Sunday, November 22, 2026

english

HAUT MONDE

POST

World

• Analysis

NATO weighs artificial intelligence in defence as trust in industry frays

NATO officials and defence experts met at the NATO Edge conference in Izmir, Turkey, to debate how militaries can adopt artificial intelligence and high tech without surrendering control of sensitive data and capabilities.

By Haut Monde Post

• November 22, 2026

• 4 Min Read

NATO weighs artificial intelligence in defence as trust in industry frays

The NATO Edge conference brought together military chiefs from the alliance's 32 member states and Ukraine for three days of talks on critical technologies and digital warfare. The question running through the sessions was how to adopt nato artificial intelligence and other advanced tools without losing hold of sensitive data and capabilities.

A networked battlefield runs on private infrastructure

Adopting high tech means depending on private companies driven by market forces and controlled by private capital demanding profits, independent of any political control - a dependency that carries real sovereignty risks for member states.

The stakes are visible in the connectivity race itself. Coordination between troops and real-time terrain analysis generate terabits of data which can decide a war's outcome and the fate of many lives.

The clearest case is Ukraine:

  • •The civilian Starlink satellite network has a military counterpart, Starshield, owned by Elon Musk's SpaceX, which Ukraine desperately needs.
  • •Since Russia's invasion in 2022, Kyiv has faced restrictions on access to Starshield, leaving uncertainty hanging over its armed forces.
  • •Musk has shifted his stance on Ukraine many times, insisting any disruption was the responsibility of Washington, not SpaceX.

Ministries experiment with trust and access

Defence analyst Tom Barton of Janes said the issue is difficult and one many ministries of defence are grappling with, because delivering a networked battlefield requires some access to confidential data.

According to Barton, defence establishments are experimenting with standalone exercises and varying levels of trust and access across space, land-based sensors and military communications.

One US company representative, speaking anonymously, said there is much advocacy for closer military-industry ties but a fine line to walk, pointing to Musk's behaviour in Ukraine. That representative argued countries do not need full control: "You don't need to be 100 percent sovereign, but sovereign enough", adding that leaders have little choice but to compromise.

NATO commanders: trust over data classification

For Major General Rainer Beeck, one of NATO's top cyberspace commanders, the heart of the matter is not the labels that govern information but the confidence behind them. Classifying material, he told the conference, is itself a judgement call - and the difficult part is knowing whom to count on. "You have to make choices about which classification you make, for which data... The problem is the trust", he said.

Admiral Pierre Vandier, NATO's Supreme Allied Commander Transformation, put trust at the centre of everything: "Trust in architecture, in data sharing, in AI agents, in decision-making tools".

Beeck's warning was that big powers already collect plenty of data; what they lack is organisation before a conflict begins, because once war starts, arranging it comes too late. A more proactive approach, he argued, is needed. Vandier also pointed to what Ukraine has achieved: "We need to close the fighter-factory gap. Ukraine did it." Nearly five years of war have given Kyiv more experience than anyone else in NATO.

Permission, not technology, and the road to 2028

Jean-Charles Ellermann-Kingombe, NATO's cyber and digital transformation chief, framed the real obstacle plainly: "The bottleneck is often not technology, but permission: classification boundaries, national rules and trust decisions". He said the alliance must make AI adoption possible at scale, keeping capabilities secure, interoperable and deployable within NATO's infrastructure by personnel who understand their value and limitations.

Smaller allies face a separate constraint, according to Mitch Free, vice president of international government at satellite imagery provider Vantor:

  • •Smaller governments need to build up their capacity.
  • •Many may own only a handful of satellites and must weigh intelligence value against build and operating costs.
  • •Commercial providers help fill the gap.

Beyond the Starlink and Starshield dilemma lies a more complex problem: so-called killer robots. Nations have agreed to talks on regulating them by 2028.

HAUT MONDE POST

Independent journalism of the highest standard. A chronicle of world culture, politics, arts, and public thought.

Publication

AboutEditorial

Newsletter

Get the best Haut Monde Post content delivered to your inbox every week.

© 2026 Haut Monde Post. All rights reserved. Digital edition hautmondepost.com.

Sunday, Nov 22, 2026

english

World

• Analysis

NATO weighs artificial intelligence in defence as trust in industry frays

NATO officials and defence experts met at the NATO Edge conference in Izmir, Turkey, to debate how militaries can adopt artificial intelligence and high tech without surrendering control of sensitive data and capabilities.

By Haut Monde Post

Nov 22, 2026 • 4 Min Read
NATO weighs artificial intelligence in defence as trust in industry frays

The NATO Edge conference brought together military chiefs from the alliance's 32 member states and Ukraine for three days of talks on critical technologies and digital warfare. The question running through the sessions was how to adopt nato artificial intelligence and other advanced tools without losing hold of sensitive data and capabilities.

A networked battlefield runs on private infrastructure

Adopting high tech means depending on private companies driven by market forces and controlled by private capital demanding profits, independent of any political control - a dependency that carries real sovereignty risks for member states.

The stakes are visible in the connectivity race itself. Coordination between troops and real-time terrain analysis generate terabits of data which can decide a war's outcome and the fate of many lives.

The clearest case is Ukraine:

  • •The civilian Starlink satellite network has a military counterpart, Starshield, owned by Elon Musk's SpaceX, which Ukraine desperately needs.
  • •Since Russia's invasion in 2022, Kyiv has faced restrictions on access to Starshield, leaving uncertainty hanging over its armed forces.
  • •Musk has shifted his stance on Ukraine many times, insisting any disruption was the responsibility of Washington, not SpaceX.

Ministries experiment with trust and access

Defence analyst Tom Barton of Janes said the issue is difficult and one many ministries of defence are grappling with, because delivering a networked battlefield requires some access to confidential data.

According to Barton, defence establishments are experimenting with standalone exercises and varying levels of trust and access across space, land-based sensors and military communications.

One US company representative, speaking anonymously, said there is much advocacy for closer military-industry ties but a fine line to walk, pointing to Musk's behaviour in Ukraine. That representative argued countries do not need full control: "You don't need to be 100 percent sovereign, but sovereign enough", adding that leaders have little choice but to compromise.

NATO commanders: trust over data classification

For Major General Rainer Beeck, one of NATO's top cyberspace commanders, the heart of the matter is not the labels that govern information but the confidence behind them. Classifying material, he told the conference, is itself a judgement call - and the difficult part is knowing whom to count on. "You have to make choices about which classification you make, for which data... The problem is the trust", he said.

Admiral Pierre Vandier, NATO's Supreme Allied Commander Transformation, put trust at the centre of everything: "Trust in architecture, in data sharing, in AI agents, in decision-making tools".

Beeck's warning was that big powers already collect plenty of data; what they lack is organisation before a conflict begins, because once war starts, arranging it comes too late. A more proactive approach, he argued, is needed. Vandier also pointed to what Ukraine has achieved: "We need to close the fighter-factory gap. Ukraine did it." Nearly five years of war have given Kyiv more experience than anyone else in NATO.

Permission, not technology, and the road to 2028

Jean-Charles Ellermann-Kingombe, NATO's cyber and digital transformation chief, framed the real obstacle plainly: "The bottleneck is often not technology, but permission: classification boundaries, national rules and trust decisions". He said the alliance must make AI adoption possible at scale, keeping capabilities secure, interoperable and deployable within NATO's infrastructure by personnel who understand their value and limitations.

Smaller allies face a separate constraint, according to Mitch Free, vice president of international government at satellite imagery provider Vantor:

  • •Smaller governments need to build up their capacity.
  • •Many may own only a handful of satellites and must weigh intelligence value against build and operating costs.
  • •Commercial providers help fill the gap.

Beyond the Starlink and Starshield dilemma lies a more complex problem: so-called killer robots. Nations have agreed to talks on regulating them by 2028.

HAUT MONDE POST

Independent journalism of the highest standard. A chronicle of world culture, politics, arts, and public thought. Published and printed daily in Paris, France.

Publication

AboutEditorial

Newsletter

Get the best Haut Monde Post content delivered to your inbox every week.

© 2026 Haut Monde Post. All rights reserved. Digital edition hautmondepost.com. Published in Paris.

Sunday, Nov 22, 2026

english

World

• Analysis

NATO weighs artificial intelligence in defence as trust in industry frays

NATO officials and defence experts met at the NATO Edge conference in Izmir, Turkey, to debate how militaries can adopt artificial intelligence and high tech without surrendering control of sensitive data and capabilities.

By Haut Monde Post

NATO weighs artificial intelligence in defence as trust in industry frays

The NATO Edge conference brought together military chiefs from the alliance's 32 member states and Ukraine for three days of talks on critical technologies and digital warfare. The question running through the sessions was how to adopt nato artificial intelligence and other advanced tools without losing hold of sensitive data and capabilities.

A networked battlefield runs on private infrastructure

Adopting high tech means depending on private companies driven by market forces and controlled by private capital demanding profits, independent of any political control - a dependency that carries real sovereignty risks for member states.

The stakes are visible in the connectivity race itself. Coordination between troops and real-time terrain analysis generate terabits of data which can decide a war's outcome and the fate of many lives.

The clearest case is Ukraine:

  • •The civilian Starlink satellite network has a military counterpart, Starshield, owned by Elon Musk's SpaceX, which Ukraine desperately needs.
  • •Since Russia's invasion in 2022, Kyiv has faced restrictions on access to Starshield, leaving uncertainty hanging over its armed forces.
  • •Musk has shifted his stance on Ukraine many times, insisting any disruption was the responsibility of Washington, not SpaceX.

Ministries experiment with trust and access

Defence analyst Tom Barton of Janes said the issue is difficult and one many ministries of defence are grappling with, because delivering a networked battlefield requires some access to confidential data.

According to Barton, defence establishments are experimenting with standalone exercises and varying levels of trust and access across space, land-based sensors and military communications.

One US company representative, speaking anonymously, said there is much advocacy for closer military-industry ties but a fine line to walk, pointing to Musk's behaviour in Ukraine. That representative argued countries do not need full control: "You don't need to be 100 percent sovereign, but sovereign enough", adding that leaders have little choice but to compromise.

NATO commanders: trust over data classification

For Major General Rainer Beeck, one of NATO's top cyberspace commanders, the heart of the matter is not the labels that govern information but the confidence behind them. Classifying material, he told the conference, is itself a judgement call - and the difficult part is knowing whom to count on. "You have to make choices about which classification you make, for which data... The problem is the trust", he said.

Admiral Pierre Vandier, NATO's Supreme Allied Commander Transformation, put trust at the centre of everything: "Trust in architecture, in data sharing, in AI agents, in decision-making tools".

Beeck's warning was that big powers already collect plenty of data; what they lack is organisation before a conflict begins, because once war starts, arranging it comes too late. A more proactive approach, he argued, is needed. Vandier also pointed to what Ukraine has achieved: "We need to close the fighter-factory gap. Ukraine did it." Nearly five years of war have given Kyiv more experience than anyone else in NATO.

Permission, not technology, and the road to 2028

Jean-Charles Ellermann-Kingombe, NATO's cyber and digital transformation chief, framed the real obstacle plainly: "The bottleneck is often not technology, but permission: classification boundaries, national rules and trust decisions". He said the alliance must make AI adoption possible at scale, keeping capabilities secure, interoperable and deployable within NATO's infrastructure by personnel who understand their value and limitations.

Smaller allies face a separate constraint, according to Mitch Free, vice president of international government at satellite imagery provider Vantor:

  • •Smaller governments need to build up their capacity.
  • •Many may own only a handful of satellites and must weigh intelligence value against build and operating costs.
  • •Commercial providers help fill the gap.

Beyond the Starlink and Starshield dilemma lies a more complex problem: so-called killer robots. Nations have agreed to talks on regulating them by 2028.