• Analysis
Trump's Lame Duck Presidency Raises Fears He Will Defy Judicial Orders
With Democrats taking control of Congress in January after the 2026 midterms, warnings are mounting that Donald Trump's lame duck presidency could see him defy court rulings, including from the supreme court. Former homeland security official Miles Taylor calls such a constitutional crisis 'very possible'.

A president without a congressional shield
Donald Trump enters the final stretch of his second term having lost the single institution that once acted as a shield for him on Capitol Hill. Democrats won the midterm elections by 13 percentage points, the second biggest midterm victory margin of any election since 1942, and they take control of Congress in January.
Critics of the president argue that the combination of electoral defeat and ageing leaves him with fewer checks than at any point in his political life.
- •Rick Wilson, co-founder of the Lincoln Project, said the impulsivity comes from Trump's age and his understanding that he is now an island unto himself without a congressional backstop, predicting he will lash out.
- •Trump is 80 years old, and Wilson has described the president as having reached his 'fat Elvis' phase, trying to recapture old magic amid crashing approval, the loss of his congressional shield and a lack of adult supervision.
- •A visible sign of resistance already sits in the Oval Office: Trump has placed a red baseball cap saying 'veto' on his desk, indicating willingness to block Democratic legislation.
The warning on the courts
At the heart of the concern is whether the president will simply ignore the courts. Miles Taylor, founder of Defiance.org and former chief of staff at the Department of Homeland Security during Trump's first term, said one of his biggest fears for the next two years is that Trump could cause the ultimate constitutional crisis by defying judicial orders, including from the supreme court - and he sees it as very possible.
"will Donald Trump cause the ultimate constitutional crisis by defying judicial orders, including from the supreme court, if he doesn't get his way?"
Taylor also said Stephen Miller, now White House chief of staff, was a man willing to go beyond the law and dare the courts to intervene. Beyond the domestic legal system, he warned that Trump's first two years of foreign policy could pale beside the latter two, questioning whether Nato survives and whether the US seizes more territory.
Restraints and unpredictability
The signals coming from the president are anything but consistent. His response to the midterm defeat has swung wildly between conciliation, aggression and farce.
- •He told CBS's 60 Minutes that his deportation push was 'too tough', a conciliatory note even as he ruled out amnesty and installed Stephen Miller as chief of staff.
- •In a farcical moment, he publicly offered the press secretary job to Dana White of the Ultimate Fighting Championship, calling him a 'violent fighter and warrior', staged the scenario in the briefing room and then said it was a joke.
- •At the same time, Miller has branded the Democratic party a 'domestic extremist organisation', advocated suspending habeas corpus to speed deportations, and asserted the US has a right to Venezuela's oil and Greenland's territory.
That duality leaves even the president's opponents guessing. Congressman Jim Himes, speaking at the Center for American Progress in Washington this week, put it plainly: "We just don't know which Donald Trump is going to show up. Is it the dealmaker, or is it the Stephen Miller pugilist?"
Bill Whalen, a research fellow at the Hoover Institution in Stanford, California, suggested one possible opening for Democrats, saying they might seek a 70-30 or 80-20 compromise because the president wants to sign something to show he is still relevant.
The White House response and next steps
The administration rejects the idea of a president cutting loose. White House spokeswoman Olivia Wales said by email that Trump will keep enacting his "commonsense, America First agenda", and she pointed to what she described as its record: a border more secure than ever, an unmatched working-class tax cut, murder at its lowest level since 1900, prescription drug prices falling faster than at any time in over six decades, and stock markets at record highs.
Allies, meanwhile, expect a fight rather than a retreat. Newt Gingrich, a former House speaker, predicted an aggressive counterattack and recommended reading Trump's book The Art of the Comeback, expecting the State of the Union to be chock-full of things the American people want.
What is not in dispute is the timeline. Democrats prepare to rein in the president when they take control of Congress in January, but until then Trump will retain considerable latitude in foreign affairs, from Iran and Israel to Ukraine and China. Whether he spends that latitude as dealmaker or pugilist - and whether he answers to the courts while doing so - is the question that will define the remainder of his term.



