Saturday, November 21, 2026

english

HAUT MONDE

POST

Politics

• Analysis

Senate Democrats leadership race turns on Israel divide between Schumer and Van Hollen

The Senate Democrats leadership race between Chuck Schumer and Chris Van Hollen has become the latest front in the party's fight over Israel, contrasting Schumer's longtime support for Israel with Van Hollen's backing of sanctions and curbs on US military aid.

By Haut Monde Post

• November 21, 2026

• 6 Min Read

Empty rows of green upholstered seats in the Senate press gallery, one with a notebook and a dropped press badge left on the cushion.

When Chris Van Hollen announced his challenge to Chuck Schumer for Senate Democratic leader, the contest between the veteran New York senator and the Maryland senator quickly acquired a second dimension: the sharpest divide inside the Democratic Party over Israel. The two contenders' records on US military aid to Israel, sanctions and Palestinian rights could hardly be more different, and outside groups on both sides have made the race a referendum on those records.

Two records on Israel

Schumer, the Democratic minority leader from New York, has spent decades as one of Israel's staunchest allies in Congress. In an interview last year he said his job is to "keep the left pro-Israel", and earlier this year he said part of his role is fighting for "all the aid that Israel needs". He calls himself "Shomer Yisrael" - guardian of Israel - even while calling Israeli prime minister Benjamin Netanyahu a "major obstacle" to peace.

His voting record reflects that alignment. He has:

  • •opposed the Iran nuclear deal, the BDS movement and a UN resolution on settlement illegality, while backing the US Embassy move to Jerusalem
  • •repeatedly voted against measures restricting military aid and weapons sales to Israel during the Gaza war
  • •backed a failed resolution requiring a state department report on Israeli human rights abuses in the West Bank and sanctions on individual settlers

Van Hollen's record points in the opposite direction. He supports sanctions on Israel, voted to block weapons sales, and advocates for the families of US citizens killed by Israeli soldiers and settlers. He opposes the detention of Palestinian children by the Israeli military and has repeatedly visited the occupied West Bank. In January 2024, alongside Oregon senator Jeff Merkley, he went to the Rafah border crossing between Egypt and Gaza to speak out against Israeli limits on humanitarian aid.

His office argues his position tracks a shift by Israel itself, saying the Israeli government has become increasingly hardline, diminishing the possibility of a two-state solution and citing indiscriminate attacks on Gaza and complicity in escalating West Bank violence. According to his office, the senator has pressed Washington to use the influence it holds to make the Israeli government follow US policy and law.

On Fox News on Sunday he pointed to growing settler violence in the West Bank and Israeli government complicity, saying "I don't think American taxpayer dollars should be going to that purpose".

A decade of movement for Van Hollen

The Maryland senator was not always on this side of the argument. A decade ago he was backed by some Aipac-aligned donors and voted with centrist Democrats on Israel. In the Senate, he has frequently invoked the Leahy law, which demands accountability for abuses by US-supported foreign militaries, including Israel's.

Several moments mark that evolution. After the 2022 killing of Palestinian American journalist Shireen Abu Akleh by an Israeli sniper, Van Hollen repeatedly met her family and pressed the Biden administration for accountability; an official report on her killing remains classified and no accountability has followed. His office said the killing underscored for him the impunity with which the Israeli government was increasingly acting in the West Bank.

He has championed the families of US citizens killed by settlers and soldiers, including Rachel Corrie, Ayşenur Ezgi Eygi and Sayfollah Musallet, and met Mahmoud Khalil after his release from ICE detention. Schumer, by contrast, issued a statement when Khalil was arrested saying he abhors Khalil's views but that his speech is protected by the US constitution if no crime is proven.

Van Hollen told an interviewer last year that he remembers the isolation of his early position: "When I first spoke out about Gaza and what I thought – the bad conduct in Gaza – I was a pretty lonely voice, frankly".

Outside groups pick sides

The opposing records have drawn opposite coalitions. Aipac moved quickly to align itself with the incumbent: on election night, before Van Hollen announced his challenge, the lobby issued a statement congratulating Schumer and incoming House speaker Hakeem Jeffries on their caucuses' wins. Schumer, the highest-ranking Jewish elected official in US history, also holds the backing of much of the political establishment and major pro-Israel groups.

The Jewish Democratic Council of America has endorsed him. Halie Soifer, the council's CEO, said "Jewish Americans have been a critical component of a winning Democratic coalition, including in the 2026 midterms". She expressed confidence Schumer will lead Democrats in the 120th Congress consistent with the values of the Jewish community.

On Van Hollen's side, progressive Jewish group Bend the Arc said the midterm elections proved that a majority of Americans are hungry for change, and American Jews are no exception. Rights groups have been equally direct. Brad Parker, associate director of policy at the Center for Constitutional Rights, praised the challenger.

"Senator Van Hollen is committed to rights-respecting policy and understands that accountability is necessary to comprehensively challenge impunity."

Parker added that incumbents who ignore the electorate's demands to end US complicity in Israeli crimes operate at their own peril. The Institute for Middle Eastern Understanding's Policy Project went further, arguing that Schumer's record as the only current Democratic senator to vote against the Iran nuclear deal paved the way for the current war in Iran.

The divide also runs through the candidates' history with each other. Van Hollen accused Schumer of having "joined with Aipac and crypto" to try to defeat Michigan's Abdul El-Sayed, whose Aipac-backed primary opponent Haley Stevens Schumer favored; Schumer later backed El-Sayed in the November general election.

A party divided

The leadership race sits inside a wider shift in Democratic opinion. Earlier this year, 103 House Democrats voted to slash US military aid to Israel - an unprecedented rebuke, but still less than half the party's caucus, with only one Republican joining. A majority of Democrats now hold unfavorable views of Israel, and the US-Israel relationship has played an outsized role in the New York and Los Angeles mayoral elections, defined heated Democratic primaries, divided Republicans and turned groups like Aipac into a liability for candidates.

Kidus Girma, the Sunrise Movement's campaign director, said support for Palestine has become a litmus test issue for Democratic voters. That pressure reaches the incumbent directly: last week, outside Schumer's Washington office, police arrested dozens of Sunrise Movement protesters demanding that the senator step up or step aside.

Van Hollen, the underdog, insists he has a "path" to win, and the race has significantly raised his national profile as an advocate for Palestinian rights. He frames his challenge as delivering the "change from the status quo" that drove historic numbers of US voters to elect Democrats earlier this month.

Schumer's office did not respond to a request for comment.

HAUT MONDE POST

Independent journalism of the highest standard. A chronicle of world culture, politics, arts, and public thought.

Publication

AboutEditorial

Newsletter

Get the best Haut Monde Post content delivered to your inbox every week.

© 2026 Haut Monde Post. All rights reserved. Digital edition hautmondepost.com.

Saturday, Nov 21, 2026

english

Politics

• Analysis

Senate Democrats leadership race turns on Israel divide between Schumer and Van Hollen

The Senate Democrats leadership race between Chuck Schumer and Chris Van Hollen has become the latest front in the party's fight over Israel, contrasting Schumer's longtime support for Israel with Van Hollen's backing of sanctions and curbs on US military aid.

By Haut Monde Post

Nov 21, 2026 • 6 Min Read
Empty rows of green upholstered seats in the Senate press gallery, one with a notebook and a dropped press badge left on the cushion.

When Chris Van Hollen announced his challenge to Chuck Schumer for Senate Democratic leader, the contest between the veteran New York senator and the Maryland senator quickly acquired a second dimension: the sharpest divide inside the Democratic Party over Israel. The two contenders' records on US military aid to Israel, sanctions and Palestinian rights could hardly be more different, and outside groups on both sides have made the race a referendum on those records.

Two records on Israel

Schumer, the Democratic minority leader from New York, has spent decades as one of Israel's staunchest allies in Congress. In an interview last year he said his job is to "keep the left pro-Israel", and earlier this year he said part of his role is fighting for "all the aid that Israel needs". He calls himself "Shomer Yisrael" - guardian of Israel - even while calling Israeli prime minister Benjamin Netanyahu a "major obstacle" to peace.

His voting record reflects that alignment. He has:

  • •opposed the Iran nuclear deal, the BDS movement and a UN resolution on settlement illegality, while backing the US Embassy move to Jerusalem
  • •repeatedly voted against measures restricting military aid and weapons sales to Israel during the Gaza war
  • •backed a failed resolution requiring a state department report on Israeli human rights abuses in the West Bank and sanctions on individual settlers

Van Hollen's record points in the opposite direction. He supports sanctions on Israel, voted to block weapons sales, and advocates for the families of US citizens killed by Israeli soldiers and settlers. He opposes the detention of Palestinian children by the Israeli military and has repeatedly visited the occupied West Bank. In January 2024, alongside Oregon senator Jeff Merkley, he went to the Rafah border crossing between Egypt and Gaza to speak out against Israeli limits on humanitarian aid.

His office argues his position tracks a shift by Israel itself, saying the Israeli government has become increasingly hardline, diminishing the possibility of a two-state solution and citing indiscriminate attacks on Gaza and complicity in escalating West Bank violence. According to his office, the senator has pressed Washington to use the influence it holds to make the Israeli government follow US policy and law.

On Fox News on Sunday he pointed to growing settler violence in the West Bank and Israeli government complicity, saying "I don't think American taxpayer dollars should be going to that purpose".

A decade of movement for Van Hollen

The Maryland senator was not always on this side of the argument. A decade ago he was backed by some Aipac-aligned donors and voted with centrist Democrats on Israel. In the Senate, he has frequently invoked the Leahy law, which demands accountability for abuses by US-supported foreign militaries, including Israel's.

Several moments mark that evolution. After the 2022 killing of Palestinian American journalist Shireen Abu Akleh by an Israeli sniper, Van Hollen repeatedly met her family and pressed the Biden administration for accountability; an official report on her killing remains classified and no accountability has followed. His office said the killing underscored for him the impunity with which the Israeli government was increasingly acting in the West Bank.

He has championed the families of US citizens killed by settlers and soldiers, including Rachel Corrie, Ayşenur Ezgi Eygi and Sayfollah Musallet, and met Mahmoud Khalil after his release from ICE detention. Schumer, by contrast, issued a statement when Khalil was arrested saying he abhors Khalil's views but that his speech is protected by the US constitution if no crime is proven.

Van Hollen told an interviewer last year that he remembers the isolation of his early position: "When I first spoke out about Gaza and what I thought – the bad conduct in Gaza – I was a pretty lonely voice, frankly".

Outside groups pick sides

The opposing records have drawn opposite coalitions. Aipac moved quickly to align itself with the incumbent: on election night, before Van Hollen announced his challenge, the lobby issued a statement congratulating Schumer and incoming House speaker Hakeem Jeffries on their caucuses' wins. Schumer, the highest-ranking Jewish elected official in US history, also holds the backing of much of the political establishment and major pro-Israel groups.

The Jewish Democratic Council of America has endorsed him. Halie Soifer, the council's CEO, said "Jewish Americans have been a critical component of a winning Democratic coalition, including in the 2026 midterms". She expressed confidence Schumer will lead Democrats in the 120th Congress consistent with the values of the Jewish community.

On Van Hollen's side, progressive Jewish group Bend the Arc said the midterm elections proved that a majority of Americans are hungry for change, and American Jews are no exception. Rights groups have been equally direct. Brad Parker, associate director of policy at the Center for Constitutional Rights, praised the challenger.

"Senator Van Hollen is committed to rights-respecting policy and understands that accountability is necessary to comprehensively challenge impunity."

Parker added that incumbents who ignore the electorate's demands to end US complicity in Israeli crimes operate at their own peril. The Institute for Middle Eastern Understanding's Policy Project went further, arguing that Schumer's record as the only current Democratic senator to vote against the Iran nuclear deal paved the way for the current war in Iran.

The divide also runs through the candidates' history with each other. Van Hollen accused Schumer of having "joined with Aipac and crypto" to try to defeat Michigan's Abdul El-Sayed, whose Aipac-backed primary opponent Haley Stevens Schumer favored; Schumer later backed El-Sayed in the November general election.

A party divided

The leadership race sits inside a wider shift in Democratic opinion. Earlier this year, 103 House Democrats voted to slash US military aid to Israel - an unprecedented rebuke, but still less than half the party's caucus, with only one Republican joining. A majority of Democrats now hold unfavorable views of Israel, and the US-Israel relationship has played an outsized role in the New York and Los Angeles mayoral elections, defined heated Democratic primaries, divided Republicans and turned groups like Aipac into a liability for candidates.

Kidus Girma, the Sunrise Movement's campaign director, said support for Palestine has become a litmus test issue for Democratic voters. That pressure reaches the incumbent directly: last week, outside Schumer's Washington office, police arrested dozens of Sunrise Movement protesters demanding that the senator step up or step aside.

Van Hollen, the underdog, insists he has a "path" to win, and the race has significantly raised his national profile as an advocate for Palestinian rights. He frames his challenge as delivering the "change from the status quo" that drove historic numbers of US voters to elect Democrats earlier this month.

Schumer's office did not respond to a request for comment.

HAUT MONDE POST

Independent journalism of the highest standard. A chronicle of world culture, politics, arts, and public thought. Published and printed daily in Paris, France.

Publication

AboutEditorial

Newsletter

Get the best Haut Monde Post content delivered to your inbox every week.

© 2026 Haut Monde Post. All rights reserved. Digital edition hautmondepost.com. Published in Paris.

Saturday, Nov 21, 2026

english

Politics

• Analysis

Senate Democrats leadership race turns on Israel divide between Schumer and Van Hollen

The Senate Democrats leadership race between Chuck Schumer and Chris Van Hollen has become the latest front in the party's fight over Israel, contrasting Schumer's longtime support for Israel with Van Hollen's backing of sanctions and curbs on US military aid.

By Haut Monde Post

Empty rows of green upholstered seats in the Senate press gallery, one with a notebook and a dropped press badge left on the cushion.

When Chris Van Hollen announced his challenge to Chuck Schumer for Senate Democratic leader, the contest between the veteran New York senator and the Maryland senator quickly acquired a second dimension: the sharpest divide inside the Democratic Party over Israel. The two contenders' records on US military aid to Israel, sanctions and Palestinian rights could hardly be more different, and outside groups on both sides have made the race a referendum on those records.

Two records on Israel

Schumer, the Democratic minority leader from New York, has spent decades as one of Israel's staunchest allies in Congress. In an interview last year he said his job is to "keep the left pro-Israel", and earlier this year he said part of his role is fighting for "all the aid that Israel needs". He calls himself "Shomer Yisrael" - guardian of Israel - even while calling Israeli prime minister Benjamin Netanyahu a "major obstacle" to peace.

His voting record reflects that alignment. He has:

  • •opposed the Iran nuclear deal, the BDS movement and a UN resolution on settlement illegality, while backing the US Embassy move to Jerusalem
  • •repeatedly voted against measures restricting military aid and weapons sales to Israel during the Gaza war
  • •backed a failed resolution requiring a state department report on Israeli human rights abuses in the West Bank and sanctions on individual settlers

Van Hollen's record points in the opposite direction. He supports sanctions on Israel, voted to block weapons sales, and advocates for the families of US citizens killed by Israeli soldiers and settlers. He opposes the detention of Palestinian children by the Israeli military and has repeatedly visited the occupied West Bank. In January 2024, alongside Oregon senator Jeff Merkley, he went to the Rafah border crossing between Egypt and Gaza to speak out against Israeli limits on humanitarian aid.

His office argues his position tracks a shift by Israel itself, saying the Israeli government has become increasingly hardline, diminishing the possibility of a two-state solution and citing indiscriminate attacks on Gaza and complicity in escalating West Bank violence. According to his office, the senator has pressed Washington to use the influence it holds to make the Israeli government follow US policy and law.

On Fox News on Sunday he pointed to growing settler violence in the West Bank and Israeli government complicity, saying "I don't think American taxpayer dollars should be going to that purpose".

A decade of movement for Van Hollen

The Maryland senator was not always on this side of the argument. A decade ago he was backed by some Aipac-aligned donors and voted with centrist Democrats on Israel. In the Senate, he has frequently invoked the Leahy law, which demands accountability for abuses by US-supported foreign militaries, including Israel's.

Several moments mark that evolution. After the 2022 killing of Palestinian American journalist Shireen Abu Akleh by an Israeli sniper, Van Hollen repeatedly met her family and pressed the Biden administration for accountability; an official report on her killing remains classified and no accountability has followed. His office said the killing underscored for him the impunity with which the Israeli government was increasingly acting in the West Bank.

He has championed the families of US citizens killed by settlers and soldiers, including Rachel Corrie, Ayşenur Ezgi Eygi and Sayfollah Musallet, and met Mahmoud Khalil after his release from ICE detention. Schumer, by contrast, issued a statement when Khalil was arrested saying he abhors Khalil's views but that his speech is protected by the US constitution if no crime is proven.

Van Hollen told an interviewer last year that he remembers the isolation of his early position: "When I first spoke out about Gaza and what I thought – the bad conduct in Gaza – I was a pretty lonely voice, frankly".

Outside groups pick sides

The opposing records have drawn opposite coalitions. Aipac moved quickly to align itself with the incumbent: on election night, before Van Hollen announced his challenge, the lobby issued a statement congratulating Schumer and incoming House speaker Hakeem Jeffries on their caucuses' wins. Schumer, the highest-ranking Jewish elected official in US history, also holds the backing of much of the political establishment and major pro-Israel groups.

The Jewish Democratic Council of America has endorsed him. Halie Soifer, the council's CEO, said "Jewish Americans have been a critical component of a winning Democratic coalition, including in the 2026 midterms". She expressed confidence Schumer will lead Democrats in the 120th Congress consistent with the values of the Jewish community.

On Van Hollen's side, progressive Jewish group Bend the Arc said the midterm elections proved that a majority of Americans are hungry for change, and American Jews are no exception. Rights groups have been equally direct. Brad Parker, associate director of policy at the Center for Constitutional Rights, praised the challenger.

"Senator Van Hollen is committed to rights-respecting policy and understands that accountability is necessary to comprehensively challenge impunity."

Parker added that incumbents who ignore the electorate's demands to end US complicity in Israeli crimes operate at their own peril. The Institute for Middle Eastern Understanding's Policy Project went further, arguing that Schumer's record as the only current Democratic senator to vote against the Iran nuclear deal paved the way for the current war in Iran.

The divide also runs through the candidates' history with each other. Van Hollen accused Schumer of having "joined with Aipac and crypto" to try to defeat Michigan's Abdul El-Sayed, whose Aipac-backed primary opponent Haley Stevens Schumer favored; Schumer later backed El-Sayed in the November general election.

A party divided

The leadership race sits inside a wider shift in Democratic opinion. Earlier this year, 103 House Democrats voted to slash US military aid to Israel - an unprecedented rebuke, but still less than half the party's caucus, with only one Republican joining. A majority of Democrats now hold unfavorable views of Israel, and the US-Israel relationship has played an outsized role in the New York and Los Angeles mayoral elections, defined heated Democratic primaries, divided Republicans and turned groups like Aipac into a liability for candidates.

Kidus Girma, the Sunrise Movement's campaign director, said support for Palestine has become a litmus test issue for Democratic voters. That pressure reaches the incumbent directly: last week, outside Schumer's Washington office, police arrested dozens of Sunrise Movement protesters demanding that the senator step up or step aside.

Van Hollen, the underdog, insists he has a "path" to win, and the race has significantly raised his national profile as an advocate for Palestinian rights. He frames his challenge as delivering the "change from the status quo" that drove historic numbers of US voters to elect Democrats earlier this month.

Schumer's office did not respond to a request for comment.