• Analysis
AI copyright Australia: Liberal senator warns artists 'must not be sacrificed on the altar of corporate profit'
Liberal senator Andrew McLachlan has criticised both major parties' approach to AI copyright in Australia, saying artists' work must not be sacrificed for investment as Labor prepares an AI policy package expected before the end of the year.

'The machine over beauty created by the artist'
Liberal senator Andrew McLachlan has broken ranks on the AI copyright Australia debate, criticising both the Coalition and Labor for treating artists' copyright as a bargaining chip in the race to attract investment and datacentres. The South Australian backbencher said the works artists create "must not be sacrificed on the altar of global corporate profiteering".
McLachlan argued it "is unimaginable that as a nation we might value the machine over beauty created by the artist", and that the work of artists "nourishes the soul of our nation". He said fair pay for a fair day's work must not be forgotten in the age of platforms, datacentres and AI, adding: "If there are trade-offs then the costs must be clearly articulated and understood."
On how artists might be paid, McLachlan said any compensation arrangements must be considered individually for each artist, because an industry-wide scheme would be hard to make fair.
A 'just terms' constitutional flashpoint
The senator's intervention has given momentum to possible constitutional challenges to Labor's plans. The legal question at their heart: if the government lets AI firms take copyrighted material, does that amount to the state acquiring property unlawfully?
Ross Cadell and Michaelia Cash, both Coalition members, have echoed the concern raised by Aria over such a scraping permission. Three threads run through the argument:
- •The constitution says the government can acquire property only "on just terms"
- •Rights holders argue that a licence for AI companies to scrape their work would breach that guarantee
- •McLachlan, as a Liberal, frames the issue in property terms
"As a Liberal, I believe property rights are foundational to a healthy democracy and a strong economy," McLachlan said, arguing the state should not acquire or trade away individual property without just compensation.
Where Labor stands
Labor is weighing copyright changes inside an AI policy suite that also covers datacentres, online safety, energy resources and economic benefits. The government has announced it will create a new AI safety regulator and impose six key obligations on AI companies, after a breach of government sites by OpenAI.
Prime Minister Anthony Albanese has declared it would be "theft" if creatives were not paid for their work. Labor's AI package, including the copyright question, is expected to be unveiled before the end of the year.
Industry and tech responses
The debate has drawn statements from both sides of the divide:
- •Some AI companies have refused agreements under existing copyright laws, saying compliance is too difficult, and want legal certainty before investing in Australia
- •Anthropic has put forward an "opt-out" model that would allow it to scrape music, books and journalism unless a rights holder objects
- •Leading voices in the recording industry have raised alarm about any changes that would weaken existing copyright law
- •Both major parties support attracting AI investment and datacentres, but the opposition has warned the government against "selling out" Australian rights holders
The growth of datacentres in Australia is expected to increase emissions and power costs for households, drawing backlash from environmental groups and some communities. McLachlan said datacentres must not be built at the expense of biodiversity, saying: "I choose real forests over virtual ones."
Senator David Pocock has complained about a major party "stitch-up" on AI regulation, as Labor and the Coalition largely agree on AI issues. Shadow home affairs minister Jonno Duniam and shadow cybersecurity minister Aaron Violi said AI was "too important to become an unnecessarily partisan political contest" and promised constructive engagement for a multipartisan approach.



